Sometimes, a good meal is all you need to make a night memorable. Other times, a good dining companion is all you need to make a terrible meal enjoyable. And then there are those rare moments when the planets and stars align, when the food is fantasically tasty and you dining companion is equally tasty in a non-cannibalistic sort of way. Those are the moments we should be hoping for when we eat.
I never planned on going to Mamacita on my last trip to San Francisco. In fact, I had never even heard of it. The decision to go there was a last minute choice over Circa, which is also on Chestnut. When I was first told of Mamacita’s Mexican cuisine, I was expecting sort of a run down and dingy place, when I could order tacos and horchata. On the contrary, Mamacita is quite the opposite of any Mexican place I’ve ever been to–it’s clean, slightly pricey, doesn’t serve horchata, and (most importantly) doesn’t look like the inside of a pueblo or mud hut. Mamacita’s light blue interior was a nice choice, but that’s probably because I’m partial to blue. And purple.
But the food is the real reason for my becoming a fan of the restuarant. How often is that just looking at a picture invokes the taste of a meal that happened over three weeks ago? The menu consists mostly of tapas that are meant for sharing. On this occasion, we did our best to balance our meal with plant/fruit matter, and more importantly, with three different types of meat (pork, beef, fish).
The jicama salad came with julienned slices of jicama mixed with cilantro, arugula, grapefruit, and strawberries in a vinagrette. While I don’t think jicama really has a flavor of its own, it adds a nice crunchy texture. The other ingredients, like cilantro, arugula, grapefruit, and strawberries, create a mix and mash of aromas and flavors that more than make up for jicama’s lack of flavor. They also make for an extremely colorful salad. I would eat this for a meal alone any day.
Next up were the tamales stuffed with carnitas and topped with mole and sour cream, and further topped with arugula (this becomes a recurring theme with their dishes I think). The corn meal worked well as a sponge to soak up the juices of the pork and sauce, and the meat was soft and tender. Usually, mole is a pretty strong sauce and can easily mask the flavor of everything else on a dish, but I think the sour cream softens the intensity of mole and allows for other flavors to come through, such as the corn meal and pork. And arugula, like always, adds a bitter taste to the dish just in case you want something not as tasty as meaty flavors.
The carne asada tacos were a tad smaller than your usual taco truck tacos, but still packed quite a punch. The carne asada was soft and smoky, not too fatty, and just a little chewy. I forgot what kind of cheese topped the tacos, but it quite crumbly, and I want to say that it reminded me of feta cheese, except not as strong. And of course, it was topped with arugula. It’s not your regular taco with meat, onions, tomatoes, and cilantro, but it does retain the essence of a taco that you could get on the street while incorporating elements that justify raising the price several-fold (like fancy-pants arugula).
Finally, we ended our meal with halibut (or some other whitefish) with ratatouille (although I couldn’t seem to find it on their online menu). The fish was cooked thoroughly and flaked off without much effort, and had a lemony taste to it, probably from some lemon zest in the crust. The ratatouille was also quite good, as it tasted more like an actual vegetable dish rather than extra chunky salsa, which could very well pass as Mexican ratatouille. I don’t quite remember what the chunk of cornbread-looking thing was made out of, but it wasn’t cornmeal. I’d like to say chickpea, but it was more grainy than that. I also really enjoyed eating that as well. As you may well know by reading my previous entries, I’m pretty good at remembering how things taste, but not what they’re called.
I hope I can return soon and partake in some particularly awesome Mexican food and rest easy afterwards, knowing that I won’t get the same digestive problems after eating Mexican food like I do at other hole-in-the-walls. Unfortunately, since I’m a student, my budget slightly limits my menu options and how frequently I can go to places like this. Maybe some day in the future, when I’m financially stable, I won’t have to worry about throwing down a Benjamin or two for a dinner for two like this. Note: the meal only cost about $70 and my stomach was brimming full, but I would undoubtedly order more food if I had the opportunity, no matter how much pain I was in afterwards from stuffing my face silly. It’s just that good.
Mamacita 2317 Chestnut St San Francisco, CA (415) 346-8494



























