I’ve finally knowingly eaten at Robertito’s, and I’m more convinced than ever that they are owned and operated by brothers (possibly battling it out in a classic match of sibling rivalry for the affection of their mother or just customers). How did I come to this conclusion? You will see shortly that their methods for food preparation are similar and entirely unique to these stores: their tacos are overstuffed, bordering on burrito status, and their burritos are just tacos with a larger tortilla, filled with only meat, guacamole, onions, and tomatoes. Every other place I’ve visited has made tacos that can be folded into a recognizable half-circle and made burritos filled with meat, cheese, rice, beans, and other toppings (because burritos need to be more than just oversized tacos).
And plus, there’s a portrait on the wall showing three brothers with arms around shoulders. Might their names be Robertito, Arsenio, and Alberto?



Since it’s called Robertito’s Taco Shop, I expected a lot from the tacos. I got a carnitas, and since my friend ordered a carne asada burrito, I ordered a fish taco also for the sake of avoiding redundancy. When they first came out on the tray, wrapped in their yellow paper veils, both taco and burrito were almost indistinguishable in size (the taco was only slightly smaller). With the wrapper peeled away, I could see why it was so large: the taco had an overwhelming amount of stuffing, almost as much as a burrito. When folded in half, the tips of the tortilla couldn’t touch without innards spilling out. Now if I wasn’t such a fatty and actually had reservations about eating food that fell out of the taco, I’d be sad to see such a waste of precious pork filling. And the pork was indeed precious-juicy, shredded, and soft, it was leagues beyond the fried carnitas chunks at Arsenio’s. Score one for Robertito’s.

My fish taco was similarly gargantuan in size, with a small salad of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions on top of two fried pieces of fish. The fish was a little dark, either because it was in the fryer too long or because it’s been fried multiple times. Either way, it tasted old and greasy. The fish tacos I had at Arsenio’s tasted-in comparison-slightly fresher and came with a tartar-like sauce, fitting of a product made with a fried fish. Score one for Arsenio’s. As a side note, the tacos at Robertito’s are slightly cheaper at about $2.29 or so.

The first bite of the carne asada burrito had a lot of expectations riding on it: would it be like Arsenio’s and have only meat or would it be like the burritos of famous NorCal and SoCal establishments, containing a harmony of beans, rice, and meat? It was the former, and our hopes were quickly dashed. These are just like Arsenio’s, containing essentially the same fillings of meat, guacamole, tomatoes, and onions. The carne asada itself was extremely salty, and was difficult to swallow without a couple gulps of horchata. My brother said that it wasn’t normally this salty, so it may have been a preparation difference. Anyway, I’ll have to give a both places a tie for their unbalanced burritos.

So how am I going to decide who wins their mother’s-and my-love? Will it be Robertito’s squeaky-clean interior in a new strip mall versus Arsenio’s dingy interior inside an old Burger King? No, this battle will be decided with horchata! Robertito’s horchata is a little too watery and cinnamony for my taste. I think this is what would happen if I mixed Cinnamon Toast Crunch with water and some creamer. And as we all know, water and cereal don’t mix. Therefore, I declare Arsenio’s to be winner by virtue of its superior horchata.
But that doesn’t mean I won’t be crossing Herndon and Blackstone every now and then for some good carnitas.
Robertito’s Taco Shop
4509 N Blackstone Ave
Fresno, CA
(559) 226-8205
Note: Robertito’s and Arsenio’s are probably not related, but then that would eliminate all the drama